Black Xs

Armaf

Italiano Nero

78%accuracy

Armaf's version lacks the deep black amber richness and intensity of the original, resulting in a lighter, less lasting composition. The top notes are slightly brighter and the overall scent feels more linear rather than evolving through distinct phases.

Fragrance World

Pure X Anthracite

78%accuracy

The clone delivers comparable performance in longevity and sillage but lacks the depth and richness of Black Xs's black amber and tolu balsam blend, resulting in a somewhat flattened dry-down. Fragrance World's version leans slightly sweeter and less smoky than the original.

Paris Corner

Pendora Scents Black Extremo

78%accuracy

The clone performs adequately in projection but shows reduced longevity compared to Black Xs, with a noticeably softer base after 4-5 hours. The spicy notes are slightly sharper and less refined, missing some of the original's sophisticated amber-patchouli warmth.

Swiss Arabian

Shaghaf Men

78%accuracy

Shaghaf Men exhibits a smoother, less intense spice profile with diminished brightness in the opening compared to Black Xs's more assertive lemon-cardamom combination. The performance gap is notable—the clone lacks the original's robust projection and staying power, fading more quickly on skin.

Zara

Man Gold

72%accuracy

Zara's version is sweeter and more linear with a generic musk base, while Black XS offers greater complexity with distinctive woody-resinous undertones and better longevity. The original's sage note is also completely absent in the clone, making it feel less refined.

Nabeel

Black O Man

72%accuracy

Nabeel's interpretation simplifies the aromatic profile, making it slightly more linear and less nuanced in the heart and dry-down. The overall longevity and sillage also tend to be moderately lighter than the original designer composition.

The clone emphasizes the coffee and cinnamon notes more heavily than the original, which features a stronger oud-leather signature. Riffs' version has a slightly sweeter, more accessible profile that may appeal to those finding Black XS too intense or animalic.