Black Xs

Armaf

Italiano Nero

78%accuracy

Armaf's version lacks the deep black amber richness and intensity of the original, resulting in a lighter, less lasting composition. The top notes are slightly brighter and the overall scent feels more linear rather than evolving through distinct phases.

Fragrance World

Pure X Anthracite

78%accuracy

The clone delivers comparable performance in longevity and sillage but lacks the depth and richness of Black Xs's black amber and tolu balsam blend, resulting in a somewhat flattened dry-down. Fragrance World's version leans slightly sweeter and less smoky than the original.

Paris Corner

Pendora Scents Black Extremo

78%accuracy

The clone performs adequately in projection but shows reduced longevity compared to Black Xs, with a noticeably softer base after 4-5 hours. The spicy notes are slightly sharper and less refined, missing some of the original's sophisticated amber-patchouli warmth.

Swiss Arabian

Shaghaf Men

78%accuracy

Shaghaf Men exhibits a smoother, less intense spice profile with diminished brightness in the opening compared to Black Xs's more assertive lemon-cardamom combination. The performance gap is notable—the clone lacks the original's robust projection and staying power, fading more quickly on skin.

Zara

Gold

78%accuracy

Brings ebony to the mix and skips praline, brazilian rosewood and tolu balsam from the original. Voters say it fades sooner on skin.

Zara

Man Gold

72%accuracy

Zara's version is sweeter and more linear with a generic musk base, while Black XS offers greater complexity with distinctive woody-resinous undertones and better longevity. The original's sage note is also completely absent in the clone, making it feel less refined.

Nabeel

Black O Man

72%accuracy

Nabeel's interpretation simplifies the aromatic profile, making it slightly more linear and less nuanced in the heart and dry-down. The overall longevity and sillage also tend to be moderately lighter than the original designer composition.

Riiffs

Café Noir

78%accuracy

The clone emphasizes the coffee and cinnamon notes more heavily than the original, which features a stronger oud-leather signature. Riffs' version has a slightly sweeter, more accessible profile that may appeal to those finding Black XS too intense or animalic.