Shaghaf Men

Accuracy Breakdown

The Scoop

Shaghaf Men captures the spiced oriental character of Black Xs reasonably well, with a comparable balance of warm spices and woody-amber base. However, the clone tends to soften the sharper black cardamom and lemon top notes, resulting in a slightly sweeter, more rounded interpretation. The longevity is generally shorter than the original, with noticeably reduced sillage after the first few hours.

Key Differences

Shaghaf Men exhibits a smoother, less intense spice profile with diminished brightness in the opening compared to Black Xs's more assertive lemon-cardamom combination. The performance gap is notable—the clone lacks the original's robust projection and staying power, fading more quickly on skin.

Other Black Xs Clones