Kilian
Good Girl Gone Bad
Last updated
Eau de Parfum2012WomenFranceLongevity · Long LastingSillage · Moderate$359 retail★ 3.8 community ratingBuy on FragranceNet $365 →
Creamy tuberose and jasmine bloom over warm amber and cedar, balancing floral sweetness with woody sensuality in an intoxicating unisex composition
Top Notes
OsmanthusPeachNeroliBergamotMandarinCinnamon
Heart Notes
Indian TuberoseJasminenarcissusMay Rose
Base Notes
AmberCedarSandalwoodPatchouliVetiver
Accords
floral· Dominantwhite floral· Dominantfruity· Dominanttuberose· Prominentyellow floral· Moderategreen· Moderaterose· Moderatewoody· Moderatesoft spicy· Moderateamber· Moderate
Best Clone
The best clone of Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad is The Queen of Sheba by Attar Collection, with a 81% accuracy score. Available from FragranceNet for $82, about 77% cheaper than the $359 original.
Best Seasons
Spring100%
Summer74%
Fall / Autumn56%
Winter36%
Best Occasions
Professional100%
Casual84%
Night Out60%
Community Insights
★ 3.8 from 8.6K ratingsWhat people who wear Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community. Created by Alberto Morillas.
Main accords
floral
white floral
fruity
tuberose
woody
yellow floral
green
rose
Longevity
Very weak5%
Weak11%
Moderate44%
Long lasting30%
Eternal10%
Sillage
Intimate13%
Moderate51%
Strong25%
Enormous11%
Who wears it
Female78%
More female15%
Unisex6%
More male0%
Male1%
Listed as Women
Day or night
Day
Night
Value for money
Way overpriced35%
Overpriced36%
Ok23%
Good value3%
Great value2%
People say it reminds them of
Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba 862Gritti Adèle 391By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad Extreme 338Mancera Wild Python 309Molinard Osmanthus Eau de Parfum 296Mancera Vanille Exclusive 274
What people like
- Ideal for elegant and feminine occasions
- Luxurious sophisticated and expensive-smelling profile
- Creamy white florals with apricot-like sweetness
- Unique complex blend of osmanthus and musk
What people dislike
- High price point relative to scent profile
- Strong floral profile can be cloying
- Marketing and name mismatch the innocent scent
- Chemistry can trigger sour or cigarette notes
What wearers say
“Well...To begin with, I had to spray it several times and quite heavily to be able to smell something. And that something is just a simple smell of apricot (osmanthus). The longevity is miserable, the sillage non-existent. The good girl hasn't gone bad, she's just not there.So I don't know if my nose "refused" this perfume but clearly, selling such a simple perfume and with such poor performance at such a price, it's just a shame.If you are looking for a perfume that smells of osmanthus, there are much cheaper and much higher quality alternatives.”
“This is a beautiful scent and would be a good "blind" buy and year-round perfume except that the sillage and longevity are nonexistent. Also this brand tests on animals, so I would def buy yourself a little tester second-hand and then maybe buy a longer-lasting dupe if you like the scent.”
“So many Kilians are gourmand I often struggle to find one I like so this was a pleasant surprise -- although Moonlight in Heaven is my absolute fav from the house. GGGB is a beautifully composed white creamy floral with super sillage and nice longevity - a great summer buy.For me it was a glorious long summer day stroll through a fragrant, long and winding wild flower garden.”
5 Clones Found
Best Match
Attar Collection
The Queen of Sheba
81%accuracy
$82
FragranceNet
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
Brings tobacco leaf, white musk and incense to the mix and skips narcissus, cedar and neroli from the original.
FragranceNet $82
Zimaya
A La Rose
76%accuracy
$19
FragranceNet
5-7 hours
Longevity
Moderate
Sillage
The clone simplifies the original's nuanced base, missing the distinctive cedar and osmanthus notes that give GGGB its refined depth. Longevity and projection also tend to be slightly shorter in the Zimaya version, with less overall complexity and sillage compared to the designer original.
AmazonJomashopFragranceNet $19
Maison Alhambra
Kismet for Women
75%accuracy
$21
FragranceNet
6-8 hours
Longevity
Moderate to Strong
Sillage
The original features a more intricate floral blend with osmanthus adding a unique facet, while the clone simplifies this with a more straightforward tuberose-jasmine profile. Additionally, the clone's musk-based dry-down differs noticeably from the original's cedar-amber foundation, resulting in less longevity and sillage.
AmazonJomashopFragranceNet $21
Dua
Extreme Rebellion
78%accuracy
$55
Dua
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
The clone trades some of the original's sophisticated floral layering for a more straightforward tuberose-amber composition, with slightly reduced longevity and sillage. Dua's version leans more sweetly floral while the original maintains better balance between florals and woody-amber sophistication.
Dua $55
Dua
Road to Rebellion
78%accuracy
$36
Dua
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
Dua's version is slightly sweeter and less nuanced, missing the osmanthus's delicate facets that add sophistication to the original. Longevity and sillage are comparable, but the original projects with more elegance and depth.
Dua $36
Other Kilian Fragrances
Spot a wrong price, match, image or link?