
Kilian
Last updated
A seductive dark blend of rum and cocoa layered with toasted coffee and almond, melting into caramel and sandalwood warmth
Top Notes
Heart Notes
Base Notes
Accords
Best Clone
The best clone of Kilian Black Phantom is Black Widow by Dua, with a 82% accuracy score. Available from Dua for $43, about 84% cheaper than the $265 original.
What people who wear Kilian Black Phantom report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community. Created by Sidonie Lancesseur.
Listed as Unisex
“Despite some suggesting this is a long lasting or even eternal scent, it's not. This is a close, intimate scent that only has decent sillage in the first 30 min to an hour. Performance is also not great, lasting 2 to 4 hours on most people's skin.That said, the scent profile is alluring. Rich and boozy, with the classic Kilian DNA. Although the rum comes through with a distinct sweetness, the coffee and dark chocolate give it depth.These darker notes are short lived though and it becomes more sweet and creamy in the dry down.”
“The story behind this fragrance is quite dark so if you're not into that, I'd advise you to find this second-hand.In the opening as a woman, for a man this is amazing! Unfortunately I cannot say the same about the drydown that's in 1-2 hours onward. The drydown smells like steamed water? Disappointing.”
“This fragrance has drastically changed since Estée Lauder purchased the brand. It doesn't last anywhere near as long and the scent profile is totally different. It smells much cheaper now, and the dry down turns into a plastic or cheap vanilla scent.”

La Ree Fragrances
-
Price
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
La Ree's version offers good value but lacks the sophisticated depth and nuanced spice interplay found in the original; expect slightly reduced longevity (6-8 hours vs. 8-10+ hours) and a less prominent projection.

Fragrance World
$26
FragranceShop
5-7 hours
Longevity
Moderate
Sillage
The clone performs adequately but shows noticeably reduced longevity and sillage compared to the original, with a slightly thinner presentation of the woody notes in the development phase. Fragrance World's interpretation leans toward a more linear scent experience rather than the original's complex evolution.

Rogue Perfumes
-
Price
4-6 hours
Longevity
Moderate
Sillage
The original has superior longevity and stronger sillage, while Abyssal Allure's performance is more moderate. The clone's oud presentation is slightly sharper and less balanced compared to Black Phantom's sophisticated woody-spice composition.

Dua
$43
Dua
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
Dua's version has slightly reduced sillage and longevity, with a gentler incense projection in the heart notes. The base performs similarly, though some users report the musk in the clone is more prominent, rounding out the fragrance's overall character compared to the original's sharper edges.
Spot a wrong price, match, image or link?