Attar Collection
The Queen of Sheba
Best Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad Dupe
81% MatchInspired by $359 original
Accuracy Breakdown
Overall Accuracy81%
The Scoop
Looking for something close to Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad? The Queen of Sheba from Attar Collection is the fruity and floral alternative people keep suggesting. It holds a 3.8 out of 5 community rating from 1,974 votes, is usually described as moderate with strong projection and is seen as fairly priced by those who own it. About 862 people say it reminds them of the original.
Key Differences
Brings tobacco leaf, white musk and incense to the mix and skips narcissus, cedar and neroli from the original.
Fragrance Profile
★ 3.8 community ratingCommunity Insights
★ 3.8 from 2.0K ratingsWhat people who wear Attar Collection The Queen of Sheba report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community.
Main accords
fruity
floral
tobacco
sweet
white floral
powdery
musky
amber
Longevity
Very weak6%
Weak11%
Moderate39%
Long lasting32%
Eternal13%
Sillage
Intimate11%
Moderate39%
Strong32%
Enormous18%
Who wears it
Female68%
More female16%
Unisex14%
More male1%
Male1%
Day or night
Day
Night
Value for money
Way overpriced8%
Overpriced19%
Ok53%
Good value14%
Great value6%
People say it reminds them of
By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad 862Gritti Adèle 203By Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad Extreme 169Mancera Wild Python 156Molinard Osmanthus Eau de Parfum 129Mancera Vanille Exclusive 125
What people like
- Beautiful blend of fruit and soft smoke
- Good longevity
- Warm and sweet
- Lush jammy peach and apricot notes
What people dislike
- May develop a soapy or detergent-like scent
- Opening can feel sharp or bitter
- Performance varies significantly between users
- Can disappear quickly on certain skin types
What wearers say
“To me this is a dry, clean smell like dried hay or matcha powder, so I can only guess the most dominant note is tobacco leaf supported by osmanthus. I don't get any floral or fruit. But my husband took one sniff and pronounced: frangipani.This smells like you just finished up an Everything Session at a really expensive day spa, giving your-skin-but-now-exfoliated-and-better.Sillage and projection are heading towards high; longevity is fair at about 6 hours.”
“It is a gorgeous scent. Peachy, floral and very feminine with a twist of tobacco. Warm and sweet.There is something about that reminds me of YSL Belle D'Opium.Queen of Sheba is sweeter.I have a few bottles of the YSL because I love it so much. I prefer my YSL Tbh. I'd have like more incense.Reasonable longevity but the sillage isn't even arms length.”
“This fragrance is refined and versatile, offering a pleasant balance of freshness and warmth. It opens with bright, inviting top notes that feel clean and uplifting. The heart develops with soft florals or subtle spices, adding depth and character. The dry-down is smooth and comforting, with a warm, lasting base that lingers gently on the skin. Ideal for both daily wear and special occasions, it's a timeless scent that suits almost any setting.”