Zimaya
A La Rose
Best Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad Dupe
Zimaya A La Rose is a clone of Kilian Good Girl Gone Bad, with a 76% accuracy score and about 90% cheaper than the original.
Last updated
76% MatchInspired by $359 originalSave about 90%
Accuracy Breakdown
Overall Accuracy76%
Longevity5-7 hours
SillageModerate
You SaveAbout 90%
Was this match accurate?
Tell us if you've smelled both. Your vote doesn't change our score.
Results show once 5 people have voted.
The Scoop
Zimaya's A La Rose captures the floral intensity of Good Girl Gone Bad reasonably well, with a prominent tuberose and jasmine heart that mirrors the original's intoxicating character. However, the clone lacks the sophisticated osmanthus and cedar complexity found in Kilian's composition, resulting in a simpler, more linear floral fragrance that doesn't evolve as distinctly through its dry-down.
Key Differences
The clone simplifies the original's nuanced base, missing the distinctive cedar and osmanthus notes that give GGGB its refined depth. Longevity and projection also tend to be slightly shorter in the Zimaya version, with less overall complexity and sillage compared to the designer original.
Fragrance Profile
★ 4.0 community ratingAccords
floral· Dominantwoody· Dominantfruity· Dominantpowdery· Dominantsweet· Prominentfresh· Moderatewhite floral· Moderaterose· Moderatetuberose· Moderatewarm spicy· Moderate
Best Seasons
Spring100%
Summer94%
Fall / Autumn74%
Winter61%
Best Occasions
Casual100%
Professional68%
Night Out22%
Community Insights
★ 4.0 from 78 ratingsWhat people who wear Zimaya A La Rose report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community.
Main accords
floral
fruity
white floral
rose
woody
powdery
tuberose
sweet
Longevity
Very weak2%
Weak7%
Moderate68%
Long lasting17%
Eternal5%
Sillage
Intimate15%
Moderate54%
Strong32%
Enormous0%
Who wears it
Female75%
More female14%
Unisex8%
More male0%
Male4%
Day or night
Day
Night
Value for money
Way overpriced2%
Overpriced5%
Ok0%
Good value37%
Great value56%
People say it reminds them of
What people like
- Excellent value for the price
- Non-irritating even with heavy application
- Appropriate for office and daily wear
- Elegant and feminine scent profile
What people dislike
- Fades quickly to a skin scent
- Misleading name with minimal rose presence
- Becomes cloying in high heat
- Requires months of aging for best results
What wearers say
“This leans more into white florals with a bit of wood, but has little to no rose at all. I'm not sure if this is Philippine weather-friendly as well (I am from the Philippines), and if you'd wear this to the office, you'd get told that you smell like a grandma, as this is a bit of a mature scent. I love it though! Grandma scents are a real classic.”
“Just got this in the mail, and it did not disappoint!I never smelled any Killian’s, but this does not smell cheap. This is my third Zimaya, blind buy.It’s giving fruity Armani My Way, the nectarine is sooo good. I’m shocked there is no orange blossom or honey listed, maybe it’s nuances.I’ll check back in on longevity and projections but I liked this out of the box with no maturation.Edit: I doused myself in this and went for a walk, could barely smell it and was a skin scent when I got home. Will try again in the heat, but 60 degrees was too cold.”
“Just got this & it's just meh. It's not aaaawful but it is definitely nothing special. I've never smelled GGGB so I can't compare it to that. But so far the longevity is weak, silage is weak, and the scent itself is just ok. Very light & airy with a little nectarine & rose. I'd return it if I could. Maybe once it sits for a while it will change. If so, I'll report back.”
Other Good Girl Gone Bad Clones
Attar Collection
The Queen of Sheba
81%
Dua
Extreme Rebellion
$50 and up78%
Dua
Road to Rebellion
Under $4078%
Maison Alhambra
Kismet for Women
Under $2075%
Spot a wrong price, match, image or link?