Rose Prick

Maison Alhambra

Rose Petals

78%accuracy

The clone lacks the sharp black pepper and grapefruit intensity of the original's opening, and the base is warmer and less mineral-driven due to sandalwood replacing cedarwood. Longevity and sillage are approximately 15-20% lighter on the clone.

Pendora Scents

Rose Addict

78%accuracy

The clone's synthetic musk base is noticeably more prominent and less refined than the original's natural-leaning foundation, and longevity is approximately 2-3 hours shorter. The rose note is slightly sharper and less balanced in the heart compared to Tom Ford's more nuanced floral composition.

Fragrance World

Picky Rose

76%accuracy

The clone's heart leans more toward geranium rather than peony, and uses cedar instead of vetiver in the base, creating a slightly drier, less refined woody drydown. Top note citrus profile is also marginally different, with lemon replacing the original's grapefruit for a sharper opening.

Dua

Rosa's Thorn

82%accuracy

Dua's version performs well on note accuracy but typically shows reduced longevity and projection compared to the original Tom Ford composition. The cedarwood in the base is often less pronounced, making the fragrance feel slightly more linear overall.

Dua

Roses in the Cafe

82%accuracy

The clone exhibits marginally shorter longevity and slightly reduced sillage compared to the original. The heart notes may lack the same sophisticated geranium-rose interplay, with the composition feeling somewhat more linear and less complex in its mid-stage development.