
Fragrance World
Best Tom Ford Rose Prick Dupe
Fragrance World Picky Rose is a clone of Tom Ford Rose Prick, with a 76% accuracy score and about 95% cheaper than the original.
Last updated
Was this match accurate?
Tell us if you've smelled both. Your vote doesn't change our score.
Results show once 5 people have voted.
Picky Rose captures the peppery rose character of Rose Prick reasonably well, with a similar fresh citrus opening and woody base structure. However, the clone slightly softens the rose's prominence and substitutes some supporting floral notes, resulting in a marginally less complex heart. Longevity and sillage are comparable, though the original maintains slightly better projection.
The clone's heart leans more toward geranium rather than peony, and uses cedar instead of vetiver in the base, creating a slightly drier, less refined woody drydown. Top note citrus profile is also marginally different, with lemon replacing the original's grapefruit for a sharper opening.
What people who wear Fragrance World Picky Rose report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community.
“I've not smelt the original TF but if this was anything to go by then I won't bother.I am a major rose scent wearer and thought this was worth a try. It smelt vile on me, I can't even describe how awful this was on my skin and there was no rose coming through. I gave it to my daughter who also disliked it so it was passed on to my 7 year old granddaughter who likes the pretty pink bottle.”
“My boyfriend bought this and he loves it, he said it smells just like the TM original. I tried to like it but on my skin it smells smokey and i do not like those types of scents. 😞 Its also complicated for my liking.”
“It's very powdery and herbal, so you're not going to like this scent if you don't like the smell of the top notes since they actually do blend well into the middle notes. This is like a powdery grassy rose to me. It's not for everyone. I can see why some people would say it gives "old lady." To me personally, it does not, but I really like this smell. Reminds me of sort of like a powdery rose stem.”
Dua
Rosa's Thorn
Dua
Roses in the Cafe
Maison Alhambra
Rose Petals
Pendora Scents
Rose Addict
Spot a wrong price, match, image or link?