PickMyClone
HomeBrandsCollectionsBlog
Browse by NoteBrowse by AccordShop by SeasonShop by Occasion
Fragrance Guides🎁 Gift Guide
Deals

PickMyClone

Find affordable clone fragrances for expensive designer perfumes.

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Collections
  • Search
  • Request a Clone
  • Browse Brands
  • Blog
  • Fragrance Glossary
  • Browse by Note
  • Browse by Accord
  • Shop by Season
  • Shop by Occasion
  • Fragrance Guides
  • Gift Guide
  • Weekly Fragrance Deals
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy

Disclaimer

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We are also affiliated with FragranceNet, FragranceShop, and others via their respective affiliate programs. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Clone comparisons are based on editorial opinion and community feedback.

We use Microsoft Clarity to understand how you use our website. By using our site, you agree that we and Microsoft can collect and use this data. Our privacy policy has more details.

© 2026 PickMyClone.com. All rights reserved.

Penhaligons The Omniscient Mr Thompson

Penhaligons

The Omniscient Mr Thompson

2023MenLongevity · ModerateSillage · Moderate★ 4.2 community rating

The Omniscient Mr Thompson is a iris and vanilla fragrance for men from Penhaligons, launched in 2023. It opens with elemi, lavender and pink pepper, settles into orris and black pepper and dries down to vanilla, sesame and oak.

Top Notes

ElemiLavenderPink Pepper

Heart Notes

OrrisBlack PepperGeranium

Base Notes

VanillaSesameOak

Accords

iris· Dominantvanilla· Dominantpowdery· Dominantaromatic· Dominantwoody· Prominentearthy· Prominentbalsamic· Moderatefresh spicy· Moderatelavender· Moderatesweet· Moderate

Best Clone

The best clone of Penhaligons The Omniscient Mr Thompson is Thunder Extrait by French Avenue, with a 79% accuracy score. Available from FragranceNet for $38.

Community Insights

★ 4.2 from 1.6K ratings

What people who wear Penhaligons The Omniscient Mr Thompson report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community.

Main accords

iris
vanilla
powdery
aromatic
woody
earthy
balsamic
fresh spicy

Longevity

Very weak1%
Weak7%
Moderate52%
Long lasting35%
Eternal5%

Sillage

Intimate10%
Moderate65%
Strong23%
Enormous2%

Who wears it

Female4%
More female6%
Unisex52%
More male29%
Male9%

Listed as Men

Day or night

Day
Night

Value for money

Way overpriced23%
Overpriced42%
Ok30%
Good value3%
Great value1%

People say it reminds them of

Dior Dior Homme Intense 2011 241Dior Dior Homme Parfum 163French Avenue Thunder Extrait 104Guerlain Iris Torréfié 94Dior Dior Homme Intense 2025 79Dior Dior Homme Original 76

What people like

  • Stunning elephant cap and luxury packaging
  • Elegant buttery high-quality iris note
  • Unique nutty sesame and vanilla accord
  • vibe

What people dislike

  • Expensive for a 75ml bottle
  • High price for limited performance
  • Weak sillage and intimate projection
  • Unsuitable for high heat or summer

What wearers say

“Female wearer of Dior Homme Intense and I get the similarities. I Became mesmerized by Mr Thompson the moment a great seller suggested it to me. It is a statement scent that exudes confidence, prepare to receive many compliments.As I can't justify the price for the full bottle (and the cap is also not to my liking, sorry elephant lovers) I just bought the £35 mini travel option instead in stores. Keeping this for sophisticated winter evenings, a night at the theatre, a winter dinner, opera/cinema night. I absolutely adore it.”
A member of a leading fragrance community
“Smelt this at a boutique and it made me laugh because this smells 95% similar to Lattafa Zanzibar. Especially on the dry down. Why I laughed is because people glaze this perfume and brand meanwhile they found Zanzibar to be off-putting. As for me, I own and love Zanzibar, and although it can be cloying, the scent profile feels unique and robust, which is why I enjoy the original Penhaligon's one as well. Good, unique scent profile for occasional summertime wear, with an affordable dupe available for the budget shopper like myself.”
A member of a leading fragrance community
“This smells like my dad in the 1990s and it took me a minute to realize that what I was smelling was something akin to the original Old Spice formula. Woodsy vanilla base, peppery-geranium middle, spice in the top note.... it's all there. It's very nostalgic. Warm, spicy rather than clean, and definitely a dad scent. It's not for me and I wouldn't find it sexy on a man, but I can see the value. However, there are soooo many other colognes that smell like this rather than pay for that wild PH price point.”
A member of a leading fragrance community

1 Clone Found

Best Match
French Avenue Thunder Extrait

French Avenue

Thunder Extrait

79%accuracy

$38

FragranceNet

-

Longevity

-

Sillage

Adds iris, tonka bean and cedarwood where the original leans on orris, sesame and oak.

FragranceNet $38

Other Penhaligons Fragrances

Halfeti Cedar

Eau de Parfum

4 clones

Sartorial

2 clones

The Bewitching Yasmine

Eau de Parfum

2 clones

The Blazing Mr Sam

Eau de Parfum

2 clones

The Inimitable William

1 clone

The Tragedy of Lord George

Eau de Parfum

2 clones