
Carolina Herrera
Last updated
An intoxicating blend of roasted almond and coffee that melts into creamy tonka bean and cocoa, seduced by velvety florals and warm spices
Top Notes
Heart Notes
Base Notes
Accords
Best Clone
The best clone of Carolina Herrera Good Girl is B.A.D Femme by Maison Alhambra, with a 79% accuracy score. Available from FragranceNet for $22, about 87% cheaper than the $176 original.
What people who wear Carolina Herrera Good Girl report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community. Created by Louise Turner and Quentin Bisch.
Listed as Women
âThis is one of my favorite perfumes I have purchased. It smells divine! I really suck at describing ingredients and notes of perfumes, but to me it is just so seductive, warm and sexy. I get so many compliments when I wear this one. It is definitely a scent I would only wear during fall or winter, but I like it so much I will occasionally use in the summer as well. It has great longevity on me. It is a bit pricey, but it is worth it in my opinion.â
âCacao, vanilla, cinnamon. Not overly spicy or overly sweet, a perfect balance.It's popular for a reason, it smells great. An easy reach, 10/10 perfume that doesn't need to be layered. Best for cold weather and nighttime. Suitable for all ages. Performance is great.The almond doesn't have that play-doh or plastic smell that some almond notes give. The bottle is beautiful but a bit awkward to spray - although that's not a massive deal.It's just a solid, feminine, beautiful fragrance for women.Bint Hooran is very similar, if you're looking for a budget-friendly version of this. It's 80% similar.â
âI havenât tried the dupe Qimmah, but I have owned the Rawaa Al Haramain. Thatâs a really good dupe for this. Its little bit sweeter and not as spicy as the Good girl, but the dna is there. I hate the bottle on this, itâs very tacky, so if you care about how the bottle looks and donât care for this design, give Rawaa a chance.Dupes aside, I like this perfume, although I hate when my perfumes are too popular and everyone used the same one. BUT I actually prefer the discontinued Legere version of this, I hate that they took it away.Longlasting and very dark feminine, like black cat energy scent.â

Maison Alhambra
$22
FragranceNet
6-8 hours
Longevity
Moderate to Strong
Sillage
The clone lacks some of the edgy coffee prominence found in Good Girl and exhibits slightly reduced longevity and sillage. Maison Alhambra's version is more approachable but less distinctive in the dry-down.

Al Haramain
$20
FragranceShop
6-8 hours
Longevity
Moderate to Strong
Sillage
Rawaa is sweeter and slightly more linear due to reduced cacao complexity in the base; Good Girl offers superior longevity and a more balanced gourmand profile. Sillage is comparable, though Good Girl has better projection in the opening.

Armaf
-
Price
6-10 hours
Longevity
Strong
Sillage
The clone exhibits comparable longevity (4-6 hours) but slightly softer sillage than Good Girl. The primary distinction lies in the base, where Armaf substitutes musk for sandalwood, resulting in a marginally less complex drydown that feels less sophisticated but equally wearable.

Lattafa
-
Price
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
Bint Hooran performs admirably in the mid-range but exhibits slightly less longevity and a sweeter, less nuanced finish compared to Good Girl's more balanced gourmand profile. The sillage is marginally softer, making it a softer interpretation of the designer's bold signature.

Pendora Scents
-
Price
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
The clone delivers a more linear progression with slightly less projection and staying power than the original. The floral notes feel somewhat simplified, and the coffee note may be less prominent, resulting in a sweeter, less balanced composition overall.

Fragrance World
-
Price
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
The clone exhibits slightly shorter longevity (5-6 hours vs 8+ hours) and marginally softer sillage, with a less pronounced coffee note that makes it read slightly sweeter overall. The opening almond freshness is nearly identical, but the base lacks some of the original's creamy depth and sophistication.

Pendora Scents
-
Price
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
The clone's heart notes lack the intensity and nuance of the designer version, particularly in the tuberose projection. Longevity and sillage are also noticeably softer, making it feel less commanding on the skin than the original.

Zara
-
Price
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
The clone delivers similar sweetness but lacks the depth and intensity of the original's florals, with noticeably reduced sillage and longevity. The cacao note feels muted, making the composition less gourmand overall.

Rasasi
-
Price
5-7 hours
Longevity
Moderate
Sillage
The clone emphasizes amber and musk in the base at the expense of coffee's prominence, and the citrus top is slightly brighter with mandarin replacing some complexity. Overall sillage is marginally softer, though the longevity remains respectable at 6-7 hours.

Ard Al Zaafaran
-
Price
5-7 hours
Longevity
Moderate
Sillage
The clone's base leans more toward vanilla sweetness rather than the original's cacao-coffee earthiness, making it feel less balanced. Longevity and sillage are also moderately weaker compared to the designer version.

Lattafa
$20
FragranceNet
6-8 hours
Longevity
Moderate to Strong
Sillage
The clone delivers comparable longevity (6-7 hours) but with reduced sillage; the tonka-coffee balance skews sweeter in Qimmah, making it less sophisticated than the original's more balanced gourmand profile.

Orientica
-
Price
6-8 hours
Longevity
Moderate to Strong
Sillage
The clone substitutes cacao with additional vanilla, creating a smoother but less gourmand finish. Longevity and sillage are comparable, though Ishraq Gold may project slightly softer in the opening hours.

Fragrance World
-
Price
5-7 hours
Longevity
Moderate
Sillage
The clone lacks some of the original's complex jasmine complexity and coffee prominence in the heart, resulting in a less sophisticated floral-gourmand balance. Sillage is comparable, though the original's projection feels more pronounced in the opening.

Zakat
$27
FragranceNet
4-6 hours
Longevity
Moderate
Sillage
Z38 is noticeably lighter in projection and longevity compared to Good Girl's strong performance. The clone emphasizes coffee more prominently while slightly de-emphasizing the cacao, resulting in a slightly more bitter finish rather than the rich chocolate warmth of the original.

Bint Hooran
-
Price
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
The clone omits the coffee and cacao accords entirely, replacing them with additional musk and vanilla for sweetness. Longevity and sillage are typically lighter than the original, and the overall scent profile feels more one-dimensional without the original's bitter-sweet coffee element.

Zara
-
Price
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
The clone replaces Good Girl's signature jasmine and tuberose with rose and peony, resulting in a softer, more generic floral profile. Additionally, longevity and sillage are noticeably weaker, and the creamy almond-tonka richness is diminished in favor of a simpler musk-vanilla base.

Dua
$33
Dua
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
Dua's clone generally exhibits shorter longevity (4-5 hours vs 6-8 hours) and slightly softer sillage. The coffee note can come across as more prominent in the dry-down, while the original maintains better balance between vanilla and cacao sweetness.
Spot a wrong price, match, image or link?