How accurate is Dua Error 426 compared to Carolina Herrera Good Girl?

Our accuracy score for Dua Error 426 against Carolina Herrera Good Girl is 78%.

Dua

Error 426

Dua Error 426 is a clone of Carolina Herrera Good Girl, with a 78% accuracy score and about 80% cheaper than the original.

Last updated October 3, 2026

78% MatchInspired by $176 originalSave about 80%

Accuracy Breakdown

Overall Accuracy78%

You SaveAbout 80%

Was this match accurate?

Tell us if you've smelled both. Your vote doesn't change our score.

Results show once 5 people have voted.

The Scoop

Error 426 captures the creamy, almond-forward opening and the floral-sweet heart of Good Girl fairly well, though it typically lacks the depth and complexity of the original's base. The tonka and cacao blend is present but tends to feel slightly thinner and less nuanced compared to Carolina Herrera's richer formulation.

Key Differences

Dua's clone generally exhibits shorter longevity (4-5 hours vs 6-8 hours) and slightly softer sillage. The coffee note can come across as more prominent in the dry-down, while the original maintains better balance between vanilla and cacao sweetness.