
Zara
Best Carolina Herrera Good Girl Dupe
Zara Deep Garden is a clone of Carolina Herrera Good Girl, with a 78% accuracy score and about 65% cheaper than the original.
Last updated
Was this match accurate?
Tell us if you've smelled both. Your vote doesn't change our score.
Results show once 5 people have voted.
Deep Garden captures the sweet, creamy character of Good Girl's signature tonka-coffee base and floral heart reasonably well, making it a serviceable budget alternative. However, the tuberose and jasmine appear slightly softer and less prominent than the original, and the overall composition feels somewhat flattened in complexity. Longevity is notably shorter, typically lasting 4-5 hours compared to Good Girl's 7-8 hour performance.
The clone delivers similar sweetness but lacks the depth and intensity of the original's florals, with noticeably reduced sillage and longevity. The cacao note feels muted, making the composition less gourmand overall.
What people who wear Zara Deep Garden report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community.
“Not a Good Girl dupe AT ALL! This one is fruity floral and resembles Gucci Gorgeous Gardenia EDT. If you are looking for a Good Girl Dupe you should reach for Zara Fields at Nightfall....People just desperately want Zara to make a dupe of popular fragrances (which they do a lot of course) but they have to stop blindly following eachother thinking something is a dupe. Compare and test first before you say something is a dupe. If you want dupes of popular fragrances Zara can be good but better go to La Rive Parfums. In this case if you want a CH GG dupe buy La Rive Miss Dream.”
“The only floral I like from this collection. I wore it for spring last year, but the scent became too sharp for humid summers in Tokyo so I hid it in the closet with the intention of giving it away. But I wore it to the office last week and this guy I like complimented me every chance he got. Longevity is great on my skin; I never felt the need to reapply. Def daytime, but not for hot, sticky days. It's not an easy reach fragrance, but it's nice to have on hand.”
“Well blended juicy pear and tuberose. Similar tonka drydown as Carolina Herrera Good Girl but I think Deep Garden isn't a dupe, they are just similar. Easy wearable and versatile. The scent changes its character in colder and warmer weather. I really love how Deep Garden develops into a tonka kind of creamy and gourmand scent during warmer days but I also enjoy its aquatic freshness when it is colder. SO YUMMY it deserves a 8.5/10 but I deduce points from longevity & sillage so it is 7/10.”
Maison Alhambra
B.A.D Femme
Al Haramain
Rawaa
Armaf
Pride of Armaf Women
Lattafa
Bint Hooran
Spot a wrong price, match, image or link?