
Carolina Herrera
Last updated
Spiced saffron and nutmeg meld with creamy vanilla and suede leather, creating a warm, sophisticated unisex composition grounded in oakmoss and sandalwood
Top Notes
Heart Notes
Base Notes
Accords
Best Clone
The best clone of Carolina Herrera CH Men Prive Discountinued is Error 407 by Dua, with a 82% accuracy score. Available from Dua for $33.
What people who wear Carolina Herrera CH Men Prive Discountinued report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community.
Listed as Men
“Opening is pretty good, versatile every-day winter fragrance I feel you could wear to work. The whiskey goes away then you can smell a sweet leather which then just becomes a coumarin bomb after 2 hours which reminds me of CK shock. Sillage is less than moderate and I only get 2 hours of projection then its on skin for another 2. I wouldnt pay more than 50$ for a 100ml, for 80$ I would rather get pure malt if you want a booze fragrance. I like the scent a lot when it opens but performance in these recent batches seems to be bad.”
“If you are still suffering the unavailability of CH Men Privé, I'm happy to report that Error 411 from Dua is a really good dupe. It doesn't just smell close; it really smells like it. It's not as boozy, but it lasts longer than the 2018 batches I owned. Both times I bought it, both times I eventually gifted it away because while I liked the scent profile, something about it bothered me. This dupe is sweeter and smoother, and super sniffable. It lacks what bothered my nose from the original. So yeah, Error 411 is a legit alternative!”
“This is one of my favorite date night fragrances. Trust me your date will want to lean in, just to get a whiff of this over and over again, it smells that sexy and inviting.It's leathery, added with that whiskey note, has some really nice sweetness, just enough to be inviting and not nauseating. It's a fragrance that I keep reserved for special days because I enjoy it so much. I happen to have the old batch and this has great performance compared to the new batches which don't seem to last that long.”

Al Haramain
$42
FragranceShop
6-8 hours
Longevity
Moderate to Strong
Sillage
The main deviation is the addition of oud in Oudh Burma, which creates a darker, more resinous composition compared to the original's cleaner oakmoss and suede character. Longevity and sillage are stronger in the clone, but the scent identity shifts from sophisticated aromatic-leather to oud-forward oriental.

Dua
$33
Dua
-
Longevity
-
Sillage
Error 407 typically has slightly less pronounced longevity and sillage compared to the discontinued original, and the vanilla-sugar undertones may feel less prominent in the base. The overall composition remains faithful, making it a respectable alternative despite being a touch more linear in its progression.
Spot a wrong price, match, image or link?