Swiss Arabian
Secret Musk
Best Montale Roses Musk Dupe
75% MatchInspired by $84 originalSave ~$51 (61%)
Accuracy Breakdown
Overall Accuracy75%
You Save61% ($51)
The Scoop
Looking for something close to Montale Roses Musk? Secret Musk from Swiss Arabian is the powdery and rose alternative people keep suggesting. It holds a 4.2 out of 5 community rating from 63 votes, is usually described as moderate with moderate projection and is seen as good value by those who own it.
Key Differences
Adds peony, raspberry and powdery notes where the original leans on jasmine. Voters say it fades sooner on skin. It sits closer to the skin than the original.
Fragrance Profile
★ 4.2 community ratingCommunity Insights
★ 4.2 from 63 ratingsWhat people who wear Swiss Arabian Secret Musk report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community.
Main accords
powdery
musky
rose
floral
woody
fruity
sweet
fresh
Longevity
Very weak5%
Weak0%
Moderate63%
Long lasting28%
Eternal5%
Sillage
Intimate34%
Moderate45%
Strong14%
Enormous7%
Who wears it
Female39%
More female17%
Unisex41%
More male0%
Male2%
Day or night
Day
Night
Value for money
Way overpriced0%
Overpriced5%
Ok33%
Good value43%
Great value19%
What wearers say
“On my skin, this is a stronger more rose forward Le Labo Rose 31. I have both and they smell similar on my skin. So if you liked Le Labo Rose 31 and are looking for a cheaper alternative you may like this. Simply rose with a woody, oudy, musk. Lasts well as it is an oil. Affordable.”
“I can barely smell anything here. I’ve had this issue with some of Swiss Arabian’s other musk fragrances, so it might just be me. Not sure if my nose simply can’t detect musk or if this is just very subtle. All I could smell was some combo of aldehydes and faint pink pepper.”
“I really wanted to love this, because I love musk. But I prefer a more powdery creamy sandalwood musk, and this is definitely a fruity fresh musk. I do like to wear it now and then, the packaging is beautiful… I’m trying to find another oil or attar to layer it with to get more of the scent I’m looking for. I’m really into layering and mixing fragrances and oils. Karina Rose by Al-rehab might be a good mix. I’ll update later and let ya know.”