Fragrance World
Edition Rose
Best Montale Roses Musk Dupe
82% MatchInspired by $84 originalSave ~$61 (72%)
Accuracy Breakdown
Overall Accuracy82%
You Save72% ($61)
The Scoop
Edition Rose by Fragrance World captures the creamy rose and powdery musk DNA of Roses Musk quite well, with a comparable floral heart that's soft and romantic. The clone performs admirably in the opening and dry-down, though it lacks some of the original's depth and woody complexity in the base.
Key Differences
Edition Rose tends to be slightly lighter in projection and longevity compared to the original, with a more linear scent development. The musk base in the clone is somewhat less animalic and defined than Montale's richer formulation.