Khadlaj
Onyx Silver
Best Parfums de Marly Castley Dupe
81% MatchInspired by $327 originalSave ~$281 (86%)
Accuracy Breakdown
Overall Accuracy81%
You Save86% ($281)
The Scoop
Khadlaj Onyx Silver leans fresh spicy and warm spicy and is regularly compared with Parfums de Marly Castley. It holds a 4.2 out of 5 community rating from 191 votes, is usually described as moderate with moderate projection and is seen as good value by those who own it. About 113 people say it reminds them of the original.
Key Differences
Brings cardamom, tonka bean and patchouli to the mix and skips akigalawood, neroli and timur from the original.
Fragrance Profile
★ 4.2 community ratingCommunity Insights
★ 4.2 from 191 ratingsWhat people who wear Khadlaj Onyx Silver report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community.
Main accords
fresh spicy
warm spicy
amber
citrus
aromatic
vanilla
woody
balsamic
Longevity
Very weak1%
Weak8%
Moderate62%
Long lasting25%
Eternal3%
Sillage
Intimate8%
Moderate64%
Strong25%
Enormous3%
Who wears it
Female2%
More female0%
Unisex12%
More male28%
Male58%
Day or night
Day
Night
Value for money
Way overpriced2%
Overpriced0%
Ok16%
Good value20%
Great value62%
People say it reminds them of
What wearers say
“Performance is a downside, but it’s a very close dry down to Castley. It’s not as smooth and not as deep, but the dry down and scent trail are very similar. If you really enjoy the Castley scent profile, this will be a really good budget option. 7.5/10 for me. Scent profile is good(soapy fragrances are not really my style) but the performance takes it down a bit.”
“This to me lasts all day on clothes out of the box, its not a fragrance I go noseblind to and can feel a constant bubble for a long time when I wear it. Ive seen a lot of bad reviews in terms of performance online for this but atleast my bottle has performed a lot better than I thought it would.I own Marwa (Imagination dupe), which has a similar scent profile and I would having both would be redundant. A silly way I can explain it is imagine marwa went to college and got a good white-collar job. I think marwa smells better but this one is a bit more sophisticated and last on skin longer.”
“Most similar to Lattafa Maahir Legacy.Currently it smells synthetic and sharp, it has the metallic citrus that reminds me of Armaf CDN Sillage. It is quite far off from Castley to my nose but it does have a similar vibe.I feel this one needs a lot of maceration, my Maahir Legacy took 6+ months to be wearable.6/10 for nowEdit:It did not get much better scent wise.Performance is still poor after few months of maceration.Waste of money.”