French Avenue
Moonstone Bleu
Best Penhaligons Sartorial Dupe
French Avenue Moonstone Bleu is a clone of Penhaligons Sartorial, with a 76% accuracy score.
Last updated
76% MatchInspired by $220 original
Accuracy Breakdown
Overall Accuracy76%
Was this match accurate?
Tell us if you've smelled both. Your vote doesn't change our score.
Results show once 5 people have voted.
The Scoop
Moonstone Bleu captures the bright, spiced citrus opening and aromatic heart of Sartorial reasonably well, but lacks the original's sophisticated woody-leather development and complex base structure. The clone leans slightly fresher and less animalic than the designer version, missing some of the balsamic warmth and metallic nuance that makes Sartorial distinctive.
Key Differences
The clone simplifies Sartorial's elaborate base, omitting notable components like gurjan balsam, myrrh, oakmoss, and the metallic accords that give the original its distinctive character. Longevity and projection are likely reduced, with a cleaner, more linear progression compared to the original's complex development.
Fragrance Profile
★ 4.1 community ratingBest Seasons
Spring100%
Summer78%
Fall / Autumn96%
Winter63%
Community Insights
★ 4.1 from 238 ratingsWhat people who wear French Avenue Moonstone Bleu report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community. Created by Carole Calmettes.
Main accords
lavender
honey
aldehydic
woody
metallic
fresh
aromatic
fresh spicy
Longevity
Very weak2%
Weak3%
Moderate33%
Long lasting57%
Eternal5%
Sillage
Intimate5%
Moderate65%
Strong28%
Enormous2%
Who wears it
Female1%
More female0%
Unisex10%
More male27%
Male62%
Day or night
Day
Night
Value for money
Way overpriced3%
Overpriced2%
Ok12%
Good value35%
Great value48%
People say it reminds them of
What people like
- Clean professional barbershop fragrance profile
- High-value Penhaligon's Sartorial alternative
- Unique metallic and steamy-ironed accord
- Inexpensive price point for niche quality
What people dislike
- Strong masculine leaning limits unisex appeal
- Misleading name lacks aquatic or citrus notes
- Lacks the complexity of original niche inspirations
- Shaving cream vibe feels dated to some
What wearers say
“Moonstone Bleu is a great Fougere that simply doesn’t last long enough. I really love the scent profile, it opens very barbershop, a little old school. The dry down is very smooth beeswax and lavender. The only complaint I have is that this fantastic take on a classic scent family only last two or three hours.Perhaps in winter I will get a little more out of it.For the price, worth enjoying it. Has become a scent I fall asleep to. I am one of those weird guys who sprays right before bed.”
“Barbershop in a bottle, usually hate any type of lavender on me but this is quite nice. The metallic dry down is where it pulls the strong lavender away, my bottle has been sat on the shelf for months and iv not reached for it since buying.. after giving it a whirl today its blended really well, smells pretty close to sartorial and lasts longer too!Quite a versatile fragrance that can be worn all year round for almost any occasion. Definitely masculine leaning. Good projection & sillage!I'm reaching more for my dupes over my niche bottles lately..”
“Lavender, honey, and beeswax. I don't get a ton of barbershop, like z14, 1881 man, bois du portugal, etc. To me, this could almost be a Naxos flanker (doesn't *really* smell like Naxos, just gives off the same vibes to me).Lasts a long time. Very strong projection. This will be heavy in the rotation in the fall time.”
Spot a wrong price, match, image or link?