PickMyClone
HomeBrandsCollectionsBlog
Browse by NoteBrowse by AccordShop by SeasonShop by Occasion
Fragrance Guides🎁 Gift Guide
Deals

PickMyClone

Find affordable clone fragrances for expensive designer perfumes.

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Collections
  • Search
  • Request a Clone
  • Browse Brands
  • Blog
  • Fragrance Glossary
  • Browse by Note
  • Browse by Accord
  • Shop by Season
  • Shop by Occasion
  • Fragrance Guides
  • Gift Guide
  • Weekly Fragrance Deals
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy

Disclaimer

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We are also affiliated with FragranceNet, FragranceShop, and others via their respective affiliate programs. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Clone comparisons are based on editorial opinion and community feedback.

We use Microsoft Clarity to understand how you use our website. By using our site, you agree that we and Microsoft can collect and use this data. Our privacy policy has more details.

© 2026 PickMyClone.com. All rights reserved.

Commodity Milk

Commodity

Milk

2021Unisex (leans female)Longevity · ModerateSillage · Moderate★ 3.9 community rating

Milk is a sweet and woody fragrance for women and men from Commodity, launched in 2021. It opens with milk, settles into marshmallow and natural musk and dries down to mahogany and tonka bean.

Top Notes

Milk

Heart Notes

MarshmallowNatural Musk

Base Notes

MahoganyTonka Bean

Accords

sweet· Dominantwoody· Dominantpowdery· Prominentlactonic· Prominentmusky· Prominentvanilla· Prominentaromatic· Prominentamber· Moderate

Community Insights

★ 3.9 from 4.4K ratings

What people who wear Commodity Milk report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community. Created by Christelle Laprade.

Main accords

sweet
woody
powdery
lactonic
musky
vanilla
aromatic
amber

Longevity

Very weak1%
Weak8%
Moderate55%
Long lasting31%
Eternal5%

Sillage

Intimate13%
Moderate64%
Strong20%
Enormous2%

Who wears it

Female15%
More female36%
Unisex44%
More male4%
Male1%

Listed as Unisex (leans female)

Day or night

Day
Night

Value for money

Way overpriced4%
Overpriced17%
Ok59%
Good value18%
Great value2%

People say it reminds them of

Commodity Milk + 257Zadig & Voltaire This is Her 204Commodity Milk - 186Navitus Parfums Lost in a Dream 144Christian Siriano Intimate Silhouette 128Mind Games Sissa 109

What people like

  • Great for cool/cold weather
  • Solid performance and longevity
  • Feminine-leaning unisex fragrance

What people dislike

  • Not suitable for blind buying
  • Potential for headaches or sensitivity
  • Can be overwhelming on the skin
  • Could be too sweet for some people

What wearers say

“This is a beautiful lactonic fragrance. It’s strong - so is a compliment getter. And I find it really does last quite well. It’s a cosy fall/winter perfume. The milk, tonka and slight sweetness from the marshmallow balanced out with the other notes. It’s not overly sweet. To me it was the most similar perfume I had found to give me a similar vibe of Jo Malone’s discontinued Oat and Cornflower and it is does have similarities. Same family.”
A member of a leading fragrance community
“Extremely sweet, yet extremely woody. This is one of the most perfect fragrances to ever exist. It opens with warm toasted smores and just a hint of spice. Despite smelling like cold milk, this fragrance remains warm and cozy. This is the smell of being wrapped up in your favorite blanket with a good book. The dry down is a heavenly sweet woody scent. This scent will easily last 12 hour days, the opening is strong but it softens throughout the day and leaves a light scent trail. This is best in the winter and sadly has to be put away for the spring and summer months.”
A member of a leading fragrance community
“It's very bold! The opening is quite synthetic to my nose, some burned plastic smell with a lot of heat that's melting your face off (personally I always find synthetic tonka bean notes challenging). Once you air it out a little it sinks into a warm, hot spicy evaporated milk with a lot of body and depth.. Longevity and projection is good - great for cold weather. 7/10.”
A member of a leading fragrance community

0 Clones Found

No clones have been added for this fragrance yet.