A Fairy Tale

Accuracy Breakdown

The Scoop

A Fairy Tale captures the warm, gourmand character of Straight to Heaven with a solid interpretation of its spiced rum and dried fruit opening. The heart mirrors the creamy jasmine-vanilla accord reasonably well, though Zimaya's version tends toward a slightly more linear presentation. The base replicates the musk and patchouli foundation competently, though the woody-amber complexity feels somewhat flattened compared to Kilian's more nuanced depth.

Key Differences

The clone exhibits noticeably shorter longevity (4-5 hours vs. 8+ hours) and slightly reduced sillage, with the cedar note appearing less distinct in the base. Zimaya's interpretation leans more sweetly gourmand overall, softening some of the original's earthy patchouli character.

Other Straight to Heaven Clones