Zara
Man Silver
Best Gucci Guilty Pour Homme 2011 Dupe
77% MatchInspired by $53 originalSave ~$-6 (-11%)
Accuracy Breakdown
Overall Accuracy77%
You Save-11% ($-6)
The Scoop
Looking for something close to Gucci Guilty Pour Homme 2011? Man Silver from Zara is the citrus and woody alternative people keep suggesting. It holds a 3.8 out of 5 community rating from 390 votes, is usually described as moderate with moderate projection and is seen as good value by those who own it. About 85 people say it reminds them of the original.
Key Differences
Adds lime and ginger where the original leans on lavender, patchouli and vanilla.
Fragrance Profile
★ 3.8 community ratingCommunity Insights
★ 3.8 from 390 ratingsWhat people who wear Zara Man Silver report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community.
Main accords
citrus
woody
fresh spicy
fresh
aromatic
Longevity
Very weak10%
Weak30%
Moderate51%
Long lasting8%
Eternal1%
Sillage
Intimate34%
Moderate51%
Strong11%
Enormous4%
Who wears it
Female1%
More female0%
Unisex9%
More male30%
Male60%
Day or night
Day
Night
Value for money
Way overpriced2%
Overpriced2%
Ok12%
Good value40%
Great value45%
People say it reminds them of
Gucci Guilty Pour Homme 85Zara Man Silver 2017 26
What people like
- Safe blind buy for most
- Versatile for office and daily wear
- Budget-friendly designer alternative
- Accurate Gucci Guilty clone
What people dislike
- Becomes cloying if over-sprayed
- Poor performance in cold weather
- Harsh or synthetic dry down
- Requires frequent reapplication
What wearers say
“Wearing it to the office today. perfect safe sillage. arms length, no more, no less. wore it for the first time yesterday and id give it around 4-5 hours of longevity. that could change today. i will edit if so.the scent does remind me of guilty. not exact but in the ballpark. which isnt a bad thing. especially for the cost. every day spring office scent for me. i dig it.”
“I love this fragrance. It's strong, got good longevity and sillage. I got complimented on when i wore this perfume. The person who was around 3-4 feet away from me could smell it. I wore it at night and i could still get whiffs of it in when i woke up in the morning. I usually spray 6 times around my neck and get a cloying effect, which means it's strong and works well. For the price it's a GREAT buy. I plan on buying a few more bottles.”
“i love this. my partner bought it when we visited London (no Zara here :[). It is intensely masculine, he only likes very heavy dark manly fragrances. I'm surprised to see people saying it has good longevity - we found it has very poor longevity. He bought it while in between bottles of John Varvatos and people seem to find that has poor longevity, while it seems to last on him all day. But it was less than 10 GBP, so you can afford to continuously reapply during the day, so overall definitely a good buy.”