PickMyClone
HomeBrandsCollectionsBlog
Browse by NoteBrowse by AccordShop by SeasonShop by Occasion
Fragrance Guides🎁 Gift GuideSavings Calculator
Deals

PickMyClone

Find affordable clone fragrances for expensive designer perfumes.

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Collections
  • Search
  • Request a Clone
  • Browse Brands
  • Blog
  • Fragrance Glossary
  • Browse by Note
  • Browse by Accord
  • Shop by Season
  • Shop by Occasion
  • Fragrance Guides
  • Gift Guide
  • Savings Calculator
  • Weekly Fragrance Deals
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy

Disclaimer

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We are also affiliated with FragranceNet, FragranceShop, and others via their respective affiliate programs. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Clone comparisons are based on editorial opinion and community feedback.

We use Microsoft Clarity to understand how you use our website. By using our site, you agree that we and Microsoft can collect and use this data. Our privacy policy has more details.

© 2026 PickMyClone.com. All rights reserved.

Home / Montale Arabians Tonka / Karus Secret Musk
Khadlaj Karus Secret Musk

Khadlaj

Karus Secret Musk

Best Montale Arabians Tonka Dupe

Khadlaj Karus Secret Musk is a clone of Montale Arabians Tonka, with a 74% accuracy score and about 80% cheaper than the original.

Last updated October 16, 2026

74% MatchInspired by $190 originalSave about 80%

Accuracy Breakdown

Overall Accuracy74%
Longevity5-7 hours
SillageModerate
You SaveAbout 80%

Was this match accurate?

Tell us if you've smelled both. Your vote doesn't change our score.

Results show once 5 people have voted.

The Scoop

Karus Secret Musk captures the creamy tonka-vanilla sweetness of Arabians Tonka reasonably well, though the citrus opening is slightly sharper and the spice profile less refined. The base is noticeably musky and slightly synthetic compared to the original's balanced woody-amber foundation, which softens the overall composition.

Key Differences

The clone emphasizes musk more prominently in the base, creating a sweeter, less sophisticated dry-down. Longevity and sillage are moderate in the clone versus Montale's superior performance, and the middle note almond sweetness is largely absent.

Fragrance Profile

★ 4.4 community rating

Best Seasons

Spring63%
Summer30%
Fall / Autumn98%
Winter100%

Best Occasions

Night Out100%
Casual15%
Professional12%

Community Insights

★ 4.4 from 304 ratings

What people who wear Khadlaj Karus Secret Musk report, based on votes and reviews from a large fragrance community.

Main accords

amber
warm spicy
rose
musky
sweet
vanilla
chocolate
powdery

Longevity

Very weak0%
Weak1%
Moderate13%
Long lasting66%
Eternal20%

Sillage

Intimate2%
Moderate16%
Strong67%
Enormous15%

Who wears it

Female11%
More female13%
Unisex58%
More male14%
Male4%

Day or night

Day
Night

Value for money

Way overpriced1%
Overpriced1%
Ok9%
Good value34%
Great value55%

People say it reminds them of

Montale Arabians Tonka 181Riiffs Perfumes Momento 69Pendora Scents Noir d'Arabie 32Al Haramain Perfumes Amber Oud Dubai Night 26

What people like

  • Accurate Arabians Tonka clone
  • Nuclear projection and scent trail
  • Exceptional value under $30
  • Lasts multiple days on clothing

What people dislike

  • Too heavy for hot weather
  • Cloying if over-sprayed
  • Nauseating for scent-sensitive individuals
  • Polarizing chocolate and rose notes

What wearers say

“This is a beautiful and elegant perfume. It smells expensive and lasts on your skin forever. Absolutely unisex. It is super well balanced, woody and musky with some light sweetness. The dry down is fabulous and lasts for more than 12 hours, eventually turning salty. I love it and I have ordered a back up bottle. Stunning. Don't buy it, leave it all to me.I am updating my review just to add that after 6 months, the performance of this perfume is absolutely nuclear. Incredible sillage and longevity.”
A member of a leading fragrance community
“I absolutely love this perfume. It becomes even more delicious after maturation, leaning more chocolatey than the original. Its projection and longevity are also above average, slightly less than Arabian Tonka. I enjoy wearing this more than the Arabian Tonka.Khadlaj is really killing it with its new releases, prices, and quality of fragrances. It is definitely my favorite Arabian brand atp.”
A member of a leading fragrance community
“This is more saffrony and less cakey/dessert like than Arabians Tonka with the addition of a Dairy Milk chocolate in the mid. It also doesn't have the oudiness/metallic feel. Sweet but not as sugary. I don't really smell the red fruits that much. It's a very good dupe and nice in its own right, layers beautifully with other fragrances. Excellent value given that Arabians Tonka has insane longevity and projection and this one is not far behind at a third of the price.”
A member of a leading fragrance community

Other Arabians Tonka Clones

Riiffs

Momento

Under $3083%

Al Haramain

Amber Oud Dubai Night

Under $5082%

French Avenue

Cosmic Tonka

$50 and up82%

Maison Asrar

Hikaya

77%
See all Montale Arabians Tonka clones →

Spot a wrong price, match, image or link?

Where to Buy

Jomashop

USIn Stock

Buy →

Amazon

WorldwideIn Stock

Check Latest Price →

FragranceNet

USIn Stock

$40.59

Buy →

See all 3 sellers ↓
FragranceNet$40.59 →AmazonCheck Price →