Fragrance World
Athoor Al Alam Ishqat Al Lail
Best Jo Malone Scarlet Poppy Intense Dupe
74% MatchInspired by $193 originalSave ~$169 (88%)
Accuracy Breakdown
Overall Accuracy74%
Longevity5-7 hours
SillageModerate
You Save88% ($169)
The Scoop
Athoor Al Alam Ishqat Al Lail captures the spicy-floral character of Scarlet Poppy Intense fairly well, with a comparable saffron-forward opening and soft rose-peony heart. However, the clone tends to feel slightly drier in the mid-notes with less refinement in the poppy accord, and the base settles into a more generic woody-musk profile rather than the designer's balanced amber warmth.
Key Differences
The clone has marginally shorter longevity (4-5 hours vs 6+ hours on original) and slightly less sillage, with a more austere, less polished character in the heart notes. The saffron-spice opening is comparable, but the poppy flower essence feels less prominent and luxurious in the clone version.