Shining City

Accuracy Breakdown

The Scoop

Shining City captures the bright, luminous character of City of Stars quite effectively, with a nearly identical citrus opening and floral heart. The clone performs well in the first 4-5 hours but shows slightly less refinement in the dry-down, where the original's vetiver displays more complexity and sophistication.

Key Differences

The main distinction lies in longevity and sillage—City of Stars maintains stronger projection for 6+ hours while Shining City fades more gradually after the 4-hour mark. The base notes in the clone feel slightly more linear and less nuanced than the original's sophisticated cedar-vetiver interplay.

Other City of Stars Clones